Thanksgiving Specials from Our Kitchen!

Thank you for your patronage. We are no longer taking orders for Thanksgiving.

For questions, please call: 845-905-4500.

Pickup Information

Order pickups will be at the Apple Pie Bakery Café Pop-up, located on the ground floor of Roth Hall.

  • Monday, November 20, pick-up available 7:30 a.m.–5 p.m.
  • Tuesday, November 21, pick-up available 7:30 a.m.–6 p.m.

Apple PiesCIA's Apple Pie Bakery Cafe Thanksgiving Pies: Apple, Pumpkin, Pecan - Order Now!

  • 9″ Classic Double Crust—$20
  • 9″ Dutch Crumb Topping—SOLD OUT!
  • Frozen 9″ Classic Double Crust—$20**
    **Frozen pies prepared for Thanksgiving pie pick-up will not be pre-baked. They are meant to be baked at home. Frozen pies will come with baking instructions, sanding sugar, and pie shine. All you need to add is egg wash (instructions included as well)!

Additional Pie Flavors

  • 9″ Pumpkin Pie—$18
  • 9″ Pecan Pie—$20

Specialty Pies (available in limited quantities)

  • 9″ No Sugar Added Apple Pie—$23
  • 9″ No Sugar Added Pumpkin Pie—$23
  • 6″ Gluten-Free Apple Pie—$17
  • 6″ Gluten-Free Dutch Apple Pie—$17
  • 6″ Gluten-Free Pumpkin Pie—$17

We try our best to accommodate dietary restrictions. If ordering any other type of specialty pie, please call in your order.

Pastries & Savory Items

You can also place orders to complete your feast!

  • Pumpkin Cheesecake—$24
    Creamy and decadent, with a spiced graham crust, white chocolate décor and whipped cream.
    6″ round serves 6–8.
  • Vanilla Bean Ice Cream—$10 per pint
  • Corn Bread Pudding—$14
    A sweet and savory side dish perfect to accompany your Thanksgiving feast. Serves  6–8.
  • Traditional Stuffing—SOLD OUT!
    This year, the stuffing comes fully prepared, just pop in the oven, and you are good to go! Our stuffing has a combination of sourdough and ciabatta bread, traditional seasoning, and mirepoix (carrots, celery, onion). Serves 6–8).
  • Hudson Valley Riesling Turkey Gravy—SOLD OUT!
  • Stuffing and Gravy Combo—SOLD OUT!
    Purchase together and save!

We sell out quickly so place your order soon!

When to Pick Up Your Pre-Ordered Pies

  • Monday, November 20, pick-up available 7:30 a.m.–5 p.m.
  • Tuesday, November 21, pick-up available 7:30 a.m.–6 p.m.

Pickup Location

Thanksgiving order pickups are at The Apple Pie Bakery Café Pop-up, located on the ground floor of Roth Hall.

Thank you for supporting the Apple Pie Bakery Café.
We appreciate your business and wish you a happy holiday season!
© 2017 The Culinary Institute of America, All rights reserved

Notice of Nondiscrimination