Create Your Custom Cake Today!

The Apple Pie Bakery Café’s custom cakes are works of art. We make it easy. With five styles, a variety of cakes, fillings, and frostings, and tiered or sheet design options to choose from, you will have a creative cake that makes any occasion exceptional. Check out our catalog below to learn more…

Sizes & Prices

• 6″ Round (8 Servings)—$32
• 8″ Round (15 Servings)—$60
• 10″ Round (30 Servings)—$120
• 12″ Round (45 Servings)—$180
• Half Sheet–11″x15″ (40–48 Servings)—$132
• Full Sheet–18″x24″ (72–80 Servings)—$240

*Prices shown are for buttercream cakes only, additional cost for additions including (fondant, custom fillings, etc.).

To order your cake masterpiece, call the Apple Pie Bakery Café and ask for the General Manager at 845-905-4500. Minimum three day advance notice required.