Thanksgiving Specials from Our Kitchen!

CIA’s Apple Pie Bakery Café Thanksgiving Specials

Make This Thanksgiving Your Best Ever!

Thanksgiving is our favorite holiday because it’s all about food, friends, family, and fun! Order your Thanksgiving pies, savory sides, and other seasonal favorites from us and let us help you get the most out of the celebration by taking some of the prep off your hands!

New This Year:
  • By popular demand, we’re introducing shipping on a limited number of our signature Dutch Crumb Apple Pies. The pie will ship frozen with baking instructions.^
  • Thanksgiving Dinner Kit—all the essentials of the feast at your fingertips—including mashed potatoes and green bean casserole, Apple Pie Bakery Café-style. Just add the turkey!
  • Advent Calendars—create a new tradition this year! Our new advent calendar, with its reusable tree design, comes filled with 24 different treats* (candies, chocolate truffles, cookies, mini cakes, etc.) for you and your family to enjoy from December 1–24.

^ Shipped orders must be placed by the following deadlines:

• 5 p.m. Sunday, November 17 for pies shipping November 19
• 5 p.m. Monday, November 18 for pies shipping November 20
• 5 p.m. Tuesday, November 19 for pies shipping November 21

* Advent calendar treats may contain wheat, nuts, dairy, eggs, and soy.

In-store pick-up orders must be placed by 5 p.m. Friday, November 22, and picked up Monday, November 25 or Tuesday, November 26.

We sell out quickly so place your order soon!

Dessert ItemsSavory ItemsAdvent CalendarHow to Pre-OrderWhen to Pick Up Your Order
  • Classic Double Crust Apple Pie—$22
  • Frozen Classic Double Crust Apple Pie—$22
    Frozen pies prepared for Thanksgiving pie pick-up are not pre-baked. They are meant to be baked at home. Frozen pies will come with baking instructions, sanding sugar, and pie shine. All you need to add is egg wash (instructions included as well)!
  • Dutch Crumb Apple Pie—$22
  • Pumpkin Pie—$20
  • Pecan Pie—$22
For Shipping Only
  • Frozen Dutch Crumb Apple Pie—$65 (overnight shipping included)
    Frozen pies prepared for Thanksgiving shipping will not be pre-baked. They are meant to be baked at home. Frozen pies will come with baking instructions. Shipped overnight only anywhere in the continental U.S. Guests can choose one of three days for their pie(s) to be shipped—November 19, 20, 21.
Specialty Pies (Available in Limited Quantities)
  • No Sugar Added Apple Pie—$24
  • No Sugar Added Pumpkin Pie—$24
  • 6″ Gluten-Free Apple Pie—$16
  • 6″ Gluten-Free Dutch Crumb Apple Pie—$16
  • 6″ Gluten-Free Pumpkin Pie—$16

We try our best to accommodate dietary restrictions. Please let us know when you place your order.

  • Pumpkin Cheesecake—$24
    Creamy and decadent, with a spiced graham crust. Serves 6–8.
  • Vanilla Bean Ice Cream—$10 Per Pint
  • Thanksgiving Dinner Kit—$120 Serves 6–8 people
    1/ea. 9″ Dutch Crumb Apple Pie, 1/ea. Corn Bread Pudding, 1/ea. Traditional Stuffing, 1/ea. Mashed Potatoes, 1/ea. Green Bean Casserole, 1/ea. Hudson Valley Riesling Turkey Gravy, 1/ea. 1 dz. Parker House Rolls, CIA Turkey Brine Mix, and a list of New York wine pairings.
  • Corn Bread Pudding—$14
    A sweet and savory side dish perfect to accompany your Thanksgiving feast. Serves 6–8.
  • Traditional Stuffing—$16
    This year, the stuffing comes fully prepared, just pop in the oven and you are good to go! Our stuffing is a combination of sourdough, multigrain, and baguette bread, traditional seasoning, stock, and mirepoix (carrots, celery, and onion). Serves 6–8.
  • Hudson Valley Riesling Turkey Gravy—$18 Per Quart
  • Stuffing and Gravy Combo—$30
    Purchase together and save!
Pre-Order: $45
Pick-up for the holiday advent calendars are the same as the Thanksgiving pick-ups, so you have your advent calendar right in time for December 1.
Place your pre-paid order any time online. You can also place your pre-paid order Monday–Friday between 7:30 a.m. and 5 p.m. by stopping by the Apple Pie Bakery Café or calling 845-905-4500.
Orders can be placed Friday, November 1 through 5 p.m. on Friday, November 22, 2019.
Monday, November 25 and Tuesday, November 26, pick-up will be available 7:30 a.m.–6 p.m. in the dining room of Apple Pie Bakery Café located in Roth Hall.
Thank you for supporting the Apple Pie Bakery Café. We appreciate your business and wish you a happy holiday season!

The Thanksgiving pies and sides order period is over.


Thank you all for your patronage.

© 2020 The Culinary Institute of America, All rights reserved | Notice of Nondiscrimination | Privacy Policy